From warfare to welfare states? Social and military spending in the Baltic States 1918–1940

LTReikšminiai žodžiai: 1918–1940; Baltijos valstybės; Baltijos valstybės 1918-1940; Gerovės valstybė; Gynybos išlaidos; Ruth Sivard indeksas; Sivardo indeksas; Socialinio aprūpinimo sistema; Socialinės išlaidos; 1918–1940; Baltic States; Baltic States 1918–1940; Defence spending; Sivardian Index; Social spending; Welfare state.

ENThis paper provides first broad cross-national quantitative comparison of social transfers and total social spending by the central government in Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania in 1930 and cross-time comparative case study of social and defense spending patterns of these three countries during the entire interwar independence period. To compensate for many gaps in the available historical statistics of national income, the ratio of social to military expenditure (Sivardian Index), used in the contemporary UNDP Human Development Reports is retrospectively applied for cross-national comparisons along with share (%) of social spending in national income. Main findings: by 1930 the transformation of warfare state into welfare state was most advanced in Latvia due to the strength of the Latvian Social Democratic Worker party. With 2.12% of social transfers and 4,15% of total social spending in total output, Latvia followed closely behind Scandinavian Nordic countries, and was ahead of all Eastern European countries. After failed Communist putsch in Estonia in 1924, bringing Left parties into strategic defensive, the advancement of welfare state stagnated in Estonia on the level of authoritarian and less economically advanced Lithuania. [From the publication]

• Du nepriklausomybės dvidešimtmečiai: kapitalizmas, klasės ir demokratija Pirmojoje ir Antrojoje Lietuvos Respublikoje lyginamosios istorinės sociologijos požiūriu / Zenonas Norkus. Vilnius : Aukso žuvys, 2014. 703 p.
• Silent submission : formation of foreign policy of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania : period from mid- 1920-s to annexation in 1940 / Magnus Ilmjärv. Stockholm : Stockholm University. Department of History, 2004. 592 p.
• Tarp Trečiojo Reicho ir Trečiosios Romos: Vokietijos ir Sovietų politikos poveikis Baltijos šalių tarptautinei ir vidaus padėčiai tarpukaryje / Zenonas Butkus. Vilnius : Vilniaus universiteto leidykla, 2019. 686 p.
• Tautiniai aspektai Lietuvos ūkio politikoje 1919-1940 metais / Gediminas Vaskela. Vilnius : Lietuvos istorijos instituto leidykla, 2014. 310 p.
• The Economic output growth of Baltic countries in 1913–1938: a quantitative cross-country comparison / Zenonas Norkus. Journal of Baltic studies. 2019, vol. 50, no. 2, p. 183-203.
• War land on the Eastern front : culture, national identity, and German occupation in World War I / Vejas Gabriel Liulevicius. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press, 2004. viii, 309 p.