Informal payments for health care services : the case of Lithuania, Poland and Ukraine

LTReikšminiai žodžiai: Korupcija; Lenkija (Lenkijos karalystė. Kingdom of Poland. Poland); Neformalus apmokėjimas; Neformalūs mokėjimai; Sveikatos apsaugos sistema; Sveikatos priežiūra; Ukraina (Ukraine); Corruption; Health care; Informal payments; Lithuania.

ENThis paper analyzes patterns of tips, gifts and bribes paid by patients for health care services. Informal payments are more prevalent in developing and transition countries because the economic and socio-cultural environment is more conducive to “gifts”-exchange as a means to maintain the underfunded health care system. Moreover, most Eastern European countries have experienced wider socio-political reforms, which have also affected health care service provision and have led to a greater reliance on informal patient payments in the access and quality assurance of health care services. This study provides evidence on public attitudes and recent experiences with informal patient payments in post-Soviet and post-communist countries, namely in Lithuania, Ukraine and Poland. The empirical results suggest a lower share of informal patient payments as well as a prevalence of more negative attitudes towards informal patient payments in Poland compared to Lithuania and Ukraine. Informal payments are more common and more expensive for in-patient health care services in contrast to out-patient ones in all countries. Still, in post-Soviet Lithuania and Ukraine informal patient payments co-exist with other types of patient payments such as quasi-formal patient payments. When clear regulation of the basic package and formal patient charges is lacking, patients experience a mixture of payment obligations.About three quarters of the respondents support the statement that informal patient payments should be eradicated. It is proposed therefore that governments of the countries should meet public expectations and implement a strategy to deal with informal patient payments. In all three countries, informal patient payments (both “bribes and fees”) are a symptom of system failure and provide a means for patients to obtain the health care they desire, which the government is not able to guarantee. Suitable regulations coupled with (dis)incentives may decrease the level of informal payments for health care provision. [From the publication]

• Ar nedidelės vertės atsidėkojimo dovanos medikui pripažinimas kyšiu nepažeidžia ultima ratio principo? / Agnė Vasiliauskaitė. Teisės apžvalga 2019, Nr. 1(19), p. 69-88.
• Assessing the frequency of informal payments for health services in Lithuania / Adrian V. Horodnic, Claudia I. Ciobanu, Colin C. Williams, Peter Rodgers. Informal economy : exploring drivers and practices / edited by Ioana A. Horodnic, Peter Rodgers, Colin C. Williams and Legha Momtazian. New York: Routledge, 2018. P. 73-89.
• Explaining informal payments for health services in Central and Eastern Europe: an institutional asymmetry perspective / Colin C. Williams, Adrian V. Horodnic. Post-communist economies. 2018, Vol. 30, no. 4, p. 440-458.
• The Vicious cycle of distrust: access, quality, and efficiency within a post-communist mental health system / Sigita Doblytė. Social science & medicine. 2022, Vol. 292, 1 pdf (8 p.).