Understanding the mechanism of individual constitutional complaints in Lithuania: main features and challenges of the first years of application

ENBackground: The mechanism of individual constitutional complaints has been in place in most European states. In the constitutional legal practice of European states, constitutional complaints as the specific procedural instrument for protecting a person’s constitutional rights and freedoms have become an increasingly acceptable, applicable, and justifiable measure. However, Lithuania has introduced this mechanism of human rights protection only with constitutional amendments of 2019. This article examines the legal regulation governing the institution of constitutional complaints, as well as the use of this institution in Lithuania in 2019–2022. The research aims to shed light on the choice of the Lithuanian model of constitutional complaints and its main features, as well as to identify the problematic aspects of this model. Methods: To reveal theoretical and practical aspects of the question under consideration, this article combines different methods of scientific inquiry, including analysis of documents, as well as the logical, systemic, critical, comparative, teleological, and linguistic methods of analysis. The method of document content analysis was used to analyse the content of relevant normative and jurisprudential research sources. This approach used the text of the analysed documents to identify relevant words and phrases, contextualise their usage, and link the acquired data to statements in specialised literature. The analysis hinged on theoretical methods, particularly systemic and logical analysis, used to analyse virtually all the aspects discussed in the paper. Comparative analysis was used to compare the legal regulation of the constitutional complaint model in other Central and Eastern European countries and the Lithuanian legal regulation on similar issues.Teleological and linguistic methods of analysis have been used to clarify the content of the ambiguously understood provisions governing the individual constitutional complaint model, the true intentions of the legislator, and the meaning of the concepts contained in the legislation. The paper also analyses the statistical information on the admissibility of constitutional complaints in Lithuania and other aspects of using this human rights protection mechanism in 2019–2022. Results and conclusion. The paper concludes that after the amendments to the Constitution concerning the consolidation of individual constitutional complaints entered into force in 2019, Lithuania can no longer be categorised among the states with a limited scope of entities entitled to apply to the constitutional court and that the consolidation of the institution of individual constitutional complaints in Lithuania was undoubtedly a necessary step. The paper also concludes that most of the elements of the Lithuanian constitutional complaint model in the context of effective human rights protection should be viewed positively and align with the tendencies existing in other Central and Eastern European states. However, it’s essential to acknowledge that Lithuania’s national model of constitutional complaints falls short in providing certain effective legal remedies that have proved to be successful in other states of the region. Keywords: Constitutional Court, Individual Constitutional Complaint, Constitutional Review, Protection of Human Rights, Central and Eastern Europe. [From the publication]

• Alternatyvi konstitucinė teisė / Egidijus Šileikis. Vilnius : Teisinės informacijos centras, 2005. 603 p.
• Individual constitutional complaints in Lithuania: an effective remedy to be exhausted before applying to the european court of human rights? / Dovilė Pūraitė-Andrikienė. Baltic journal of law & politics. 2022, Vol. 15, Nr. 1, p. 1-30.
• Individualus konstitucinis skundas kaip veiksmingas žmogaus teisių apsaugos ir konstitucionalizmo plėtros instrumentas / Dovilė Pūraitė-Andrikienė. Teisė. 2015, t. 96, p. 201-224.
• Konstitucinė justicija Lietuvoje : pirmasis dešimtmetis / Egidijus Kūris. Konstitucinis teisingumas ir teisės viešpatavimas : tarptautinė konferencija, skirta Lietuvos Respublikos Konstitucinio Teismo įsteigimo 10-mečiui, 2003 m. rugsėjo 4 d., Vilnius. Vilnius: Lietuvos Respublikos Konstitucinis Teismas, 2004. P. 22-45.
• Konstitucinės justicijos procesas Lietuvoje : optimalaus modelio paieška : disertacija / Dovilė Pūraitė-Andrikienė. Vilnius, 2017. 1 pdf (536 p.).
• Konstituciniai ginčai / Toma Birmontienė, Ingrida Danėlienė, Egidijus Jarašiūnas, Vytautas Sinkevičius, Dainius Žalimas. Vilnius : Mykolo Romerio universitetas, 2019. 637 p.
• Konstitucinio Teismo nutarimų padariniai laiko aspektu / Dovilė Pūraitė-Andrikienė. Teisė. 2019, t. 112, p. 70-90.
• Lietuvoje įtvirtintas konstitucinio skundo institutas kaip žmogaus teisių apsaugos įrankis / Dovilė Pūraitė-Andrikienė. Vilnius : Vilniaus universiteto leidykla, 2022. 302 p.
• Lietuvos individualaus konstitucinio skundo modelio privalumai ir trūkumai / Dovilė Pūraitė-Andrikienė. Teisė. 2020, t. 114, p. 49-70.
• Lietuvos Respublikos Konstitucinio Teismo nutarimų teisinė galia laiko požiūriu / Viktorija Staugaitytė. Jurisprudencija. 2005, Nr. 77 (69), p. 65-81.
• Teisės aktų konstitucingumo patikros objektai Lietuvos Respublikos Konstitucinio Teismo jurisprudencijoje / Dovilė Pūraitė-Andrikienė. Teisė. 2020, t. 116, p. 72-91.
• The Development and prospects of the Lithuanian constitutional justice model / Dovilė Pūraitė-Andrikienė. Legal developments during 30 years of Lithuanian independence: overview of legal accomplishments and challenges in Lithuania / editors: Gintaras Švedas, Donatas Murauskas. Cham : Springer, 2021. P. 225-243.
• The Legal force of conclusions by the Lithuanian Constitutional Court and the issue of their (non-)finality: has the time come to amend the Constitution? / Dovilė Pūraitė-Andrikienė. Review of Central and East European law. 2019, vol. 44, no. 2, p. 232-268.
• Žmogaus teisių apsaugos institucijos / Egidijus Jarašiūnas, Edita Žiobienė, Inga Žalėnienė, Saulė Vidrinskaitė, Dovilė Gailiūtė. Vilnius : Mykolo Romerio universitetas, 2009. 445 p.
• Žmogaus teisių apsaugos stiprinimas konstitucinio skundo institutu / Lina Beliūnienė. Vilnius : Justitia, 2014. 222 p.