From rhetoric to reality: Lithuania’s total defence response to Russian threats

ENThis research delves into Lithuania’s response to the perceived threat from Russia and the practical implementation of its total defence approach. Key political figures, including the President, Prime Minister, Minister of National Defence, and Chairman of the National Security and Defence Committee, are scrutinized using securitization theory. The study explores how these actors frame total defence as an urgent response to an existential threat and analyses both their discourse and tangible actions from 2020 onwards. Distinct approaches among political figures emerge, with the President prioritizing communication, the Minister of Defence emphasizing tangible improvements, and the Chairman of the NSDC acting as a driving force. Despite increased military spending, the involvement of society in national defence—integral to the total defence strategy—remains limited. Factors contributing to this limitation include unclear leadership, insincere rhetoric, bureaucratic obstacles, and the initial unpreparedness of the Armed Forces to integrate civilians. The study underscores the critical need for genuine commitment and leadership to achieve meaningful breakthroughs in Lithuania’s total defence approach. While politicians employ securitization and public discourse to align with public sentiment and present themselves as problem solvers, the actual progress in engaging the public and the private sector remains limited. The discrepancy between discourse and material implementation suggests that a more substantial commitment is essential for effective societal involvement in national defence, making it clear that symbolic gestures fall short of achieving impactful results in Lithuania’s total defence approach. Keywords: Lithuania, total defence, securitization, political discourse, Russia. [From the publication]

• Ar Lietuvos gyventojai jaučiasi saugūs? : subjektyvus saugumas kintančiame geopolitiniame kontekste / Diana Janušauskienė, Eglė Vileikienė, Laima Nevinskaitė, Ingrida Gečienė-Janulionė. Vilnius : Lietuvos socialinių tyrimų centras, 2017. 148 p.
• Facing past, present, and future: the role of historical beliefs and experiences in the Lithuanian public perception of military threats / Ainius Lašas, Irmina Matonytė, Vaida Jankauskaitė. Journal of Baltic studies. 2020, vol. 51, no. 2, p. 199-221.
• Grėsmių visuomenės gerovei suvokimas : socialinio optimizmo, socialinio ir institucinio pasitikėjimo bei pasitikėjimo savimi įtaka / Irmina Matonytė, Vaidas Morkevičius, Ainius Lašas, Vaida Jankauskaitė. Politologija. 2017, Nr. 1 (85), p. 3-55.
• Kas eitų ginti Lietuvos? : pilietinio pasipriešinimo prielaidos ir galimybės / Ainė Ramonaitė, Ieva Petronytė-Urbonavičienė, Paulius Skirkevičius, Eugenijus Vosylius. Vilnius : Aukso žuvys, 2018. 199 p.
• Lietuvos gyventojų požiūrio į saugumą analizė.. Lietuvos metinė strateginė apžvalga. 2003, t. 1, p. 277-298.
• Lithuanian military transformation and changing efficiency of defence / Deividas Šlekys. Lithuania in the global context: national security and defence policy dilemmas / by editors Irmina Matonytė, Giedrius Česnakas and Nortautas Statkus. Vilnius: General Jonas Žemaitis Military Academy of Lithuania, 2020. P. 307-325.
• Mąslaus Vyčio beieškant : lietuviškos karinės minties raida ir būklė po nepriklausomybės atkūrimo (1990-2014) / Deividas Šlekys. Vilnius : Generolo Jono Žemaičio Lietuvos karo akademija, 2015. 234 p.
• Securitization of the energy sectors in Estonia, Lithuania, Poland and Ukraine: motives and extraordinary measures / Tomas Janeliūnas, Agnija Tumkevič. Lithuanian foreign policy review. 2013, vol. 30, p. 65-90.
• Security culture of Lithuania / Maragarita Šešelgytė. Lithuanian foreign policy review. 2010, 24, p. 23-40.
• Strengthening resilience of Lithuania in an era of great power competition: the case for total defence / Liudas Zdanavičius, Nortautas Statkus. Journal on Baltic security. 2020, vol. 6, no. 2, p. 47-67.
• Subjective security in a volatile geopolitical situation : does Lithuanian society feel safe? / Eglė Vileikienė, Diana Janušauskienė. Journal on Baltic security. 2016, vol. 2, no. 2, p. 109-143.
• Valia priešintis: paramilitarizmas ir Lietuvos karinio saugumo problemos / Vytautas Jokubauskas, Jonas Vaičenonis, Vygantas Vareikis, Hektoras Vitkus. Klaipėda : Druka, 2015. 319 p.
• Žiniasklaidos poveikis karinių grėsmių vertinimui / Gintaras Šumskas, Irmina Matonytė. Lietuvos metinė strateginė apžvalga. 2018, t. 16, p. 415-442.