Gender and sentencing in Lithuania: more mercy for women?
ENThis article focuses on the structure of female and male crimes and gender disparities in sentencing in Lithuania, which present a significant gap in criminological research. Using Lithuanian court decisions on five types of offenses—murder, grievous bodily harm, actual bodily harm, drug distribution, and theft—we attempt to answer whether women are punished more leniently than men. Our research demonstrates that gender is a significant factor only in some sentences. Only the length of a prison sentence showed a statistically significant difference. When the importance of legal and extralegal factors in imposing prison length is compared, legal factors are found to be more significant predictors. The prison sentence length was mainly affected by the presence of a prior conviction, additional charges, and mitigating and aggravating circumstances. Although the average prison sentence for men in cases of grievous bodily harm and drug distribution was significantly longer than for women, the regression models developed for each offence type revealed that neither gender nor other extralegal factors appeared to be significant in determining the length of the prison sentence. The results allow us to argue that future research should focus more on analyzing extralegal factors and judges’ motives in discretionary sentencing decisions. Keywords: women’s sentencing; court decisions; disparities in sentencing; Lithuania. [From the publication]
- Kalinimo sąlygos ir kalinių socialinės integracijos prielaidos / Gintautas Sakalauskas, Liubovė Jarutienė, Vaidas Kalpokas, Rūta Vaičiūnienė. Vilnius : Lietuvos teisės institutas, 2020. 516 p.
- Moterys Lietuvos baudžiamojo teisingumo sistemoje: nuo baudimo praktikų iki bausmės patirčių / Artūras Tereškinas, Rūta Vaičiūnienė, Simonas Nikartas, Liubovė Jarutienė. Vilnius : Žara, 2021. 200 p.
- Moterų nusikalstamo elgesio problematika / Ilona Michailovič. Teisė. 2014, t. 93 p. 82-94.
- Nusikaltimų prevencijos programų Lietuvoje nuostatos: tarp absurdo ir kokybės / Gintautas Sakalauskas. Kriminologijos studijos. 2016, Nr. 4, p. 72-97.
- Socialinio tyrimo išvada nagrinėjant baudžiamąsias bylas / Ilona Michailovič, Mindaugas Girdauskas. Baudžiamoji justicija ir verslas. Vilnius: Vilniaus universitetas, 2016. P. 417-436.
